Toggle Menu

Insights > Agile Transformation > Defects in the Agile World – Four Key Questions (Part 3)

Defects in the Agile World – Four Key Questions (Part 3)

Each of the three questions addressed in my previous posts (Part 1 and Part 2) examines defects from a different perspective, and they all should be considered collectively when making a judgment call on a defect. A couple of additional questions should also be addressed when implementing such a hybrid solution: Do We Size Defects […]

By

February 09, 2016

Each of the three questions addressed in my previous posts (Part 1 and Part 2) examines defects from a different perspective, and they all should be considered collectively when making a judgment call on a defect. A couple of additional questions should also be addressed when implementing such a hybrid solution:

Do We Size Defects in the Backlog?

If the defect is to be added to the backlog, then, given it is now a PBI, it should be sized. Mike Cohn, a leading Agile coach, recommends sizing defects similar to what we do for user stories. This has two advantages. First, the velocity will more accurately report the work done by the Scrum Development Team. Second, this leads to a better defect management in instances where the team has a significant defect load (e.g. legacy or operation/maintenance type defects).

Do We Create a Separate Backlog for Defects?

From a Scrum perspective, the answer is No. As mentioned earlier, the defects should be treated as PBIs. They should be owned, prioritized, sized, and signed off by the Product Owner. Having one Backlog would ensure that the team’s focus is on one place only.

Be mindful of the Agile principles

Whichever process you decide best fits your team, always be mindful of the 12 Agile principles.

The following principles are of particular interest to this defect management discussion:

Overall, the good practices discussed here should be looked at as a guiding tool. Try them, see how they work, and inspect and adapt when needed. Be Agile!

References & Further Readings:

Handling Bugs in an Agile Context

Coping with Bugs on an Agile/Scrum Project

Keeping Agile with Zero-Bug/Defect Policy

Should Story Points Be Assigned to a Bug Fixing Story?

Dealing with Bugs in the Product Backlog

You Might Also Like

Agile Transformation

Agile Requirements: Process and Scope

Getting Agile requirements right can be a challenge but it’s essential as they can make...

Agile Transformation

3 Keys to Agile Scaling: The View of Our Experts

Scaling, like Agile itself, can become a target objective rather than the means to an...

Agile Transformation

6 Signs Your Agile Scaling Isn’t Working

In our last post on Agile scaling, we described some signs that indicate you should...